The common methods for measuring the consistency in concrete are the Slump test, flow table test, and Vebe test. This important concrete property is affected by different factors, including water-cement ratio, aggregate type, and admixtures.
When it comes to construction projects, the consistency of concrete plays a crucial role in the overall success and durability of structures.
Concrete consistency refers to the degree of wetness or fluidity of freshly mixed concrete. Long story short, the “wetness” of concrete not only affects its workability but also drastically affects the longevity of the whole building.
What factors affect the consistency of concrete, and how do you test this important concrete property? This article will answer these questions.
We’ll dive deep into the world of concrete consistency to look at its relationship with workability and the different factors that affect it. We’ll also discuss how you can measure the consistency of concrete accurately using Certified MTP’s high-quality equipment. So, let’s dive in.
At the end of this article, you’ll be one step closer to assuring the quality of concrete to deliver strong and durable construction projects.
What are the Factors Affecting Concrete Consistency?
When working with consistency in concrete, you need it to be fluid (so it is easy to mix, place, and finish) while maintaining the desired properties and performance. Adding water to cement causes a chemical reaction that binds the cement with the aggregate, affecting the consistency.
Several factors affect concrete consistency/ fluidity, and controlling these factors helps you achieve the desired workability and performance of the concrete mix.
Here are some key factors that affect concrete consistency:
1. Water-to-cement ratio
The water ratio of water to cement in your concrete mix directly affects the consistency in concrete. It determines the amount of water relative to the cement content in your concrete mix.
Too little water can lead to low workability and difficulties when placing concrete, while a higher water-cement ratio results in more workable concrete. However, too much water can lead to segregation and decreased strength.
2. Aggregate type
The size, shape, and gradation of aggregates influence the consistency in concrete mix.
The aggregates are the granular materials that make up the dry mix and wet concrete mix, like sand, gravel, and crushed stone. Fine aggregates require more water to make them workable. So, fine aggregates have lower workability.
On the other hand, the larger particles of coarse aggregates demand less water to make them workable. So, coarse aggregates have higher workability.
When designing concrete mixtures, choosing the right combination of coarse and fine aggregates is crucial to creating the right consistency in concrete, and the same consistency consistently, for your purposes.
3. Admixtures and additives
You’ll find that many dry concrete mixes contain other additives. These chemical and mineral admixtures can alter the consistency in concrete, either by increasing or decreasing its fluidity.
Temperature and weather conditions for freshly mixed concrete
The temperature of the concrete and the ambient temperature can impact the consistency in concrete, causing it to set too quickly or slowly.
Generally, higher temperatures accelerate setting time and reduce concrete workability, while lower temperatures slow down setting and increase workability.
Techniques for Measuring the Consistency in Concrete?
Since the consistency in concrete is so important, you need accurate ways to measure it. Measuring the consistency of freshly mixed concrete is crucial to ensure the desired properties are maintained throughout the construction process.
There are different techniques for measuring the consistency of concrete. Generally speaking, you’ll need to consider the specific type of concrete mix you are working with, your expertise with concrete, and your budget to determine which testing method is the best choice for your needs.
That said, some common test methods for measuring the consistency in concrete are:
1. Slump Test
Mixing concrete properly is crucial for preparing the concrete for the slump test, which is a simple way to measure the workability and consistency in concrete that is fresh.
You fill a cone-shaped container, called a slump cone, with concrete in three layers, compacting each layer with a tamping rod. Then, you level the top and remove the cone by lifting it straight up a thin wall.
The concrete will “slump” or settle, and you measure the difference in height between the top of the cone and the highest point of the slumped concrete. This measurement (called the “slump value”) helps you understand how easily the concrete can be placed and compacted.
A higher slump value means the mix is more fluid and workable, while a lower value indicates a stiffer mix.
This test is quick and easy and widely used across the industry.
Check out our various options for slump test equipment that can help you accurately measure concrete consistency.
Flow table test
The flow table test is another method for measuring the workability and consistency in concrete that is fresh. For this test, you typically use a wheelbarrow as a mixing container to prepare the concrete before placing it on the flow table.
In this test, you place a specific amount of concrete on a flat, round table called a flow table. You then lift and drop the table several times, causing the concrete to spread out.
After completing the table drops, you measure the diameter of the spread concrete to assess the relative mobility. The greater the spread, the more fluid (and therefore workable) the concrete mix is. It isn’t particularly workable if it only flows sluggishly and stays relatively central to the flow table.
The flow table test provides a visual representation to help you predict how the concrete will behave during placement, helping you determine if the mix is suitable for your project.
Take a look at the various flow table products available through Certified MTP.
3. Vebe test
Our third method is the Vebe test, which works especially well for mixing stiffer mixes. It is crucial to use thoroughly mixed concrete to ensure accurate Vebe test results.
In this test, you place a known volume of concrete in a cylindrical container and then cover it with a transparent, disc-shaped lid with a hole in the center. You then use a vibrating table to shake the container, allowing the concrete to spread and settle.
You then measure the time it takes for the concrete to resettle in its original volume under the vibration. This duration is known as the “Vebe time.” A shorter Vebe time indicates a more workable and fluid mix, while a longer Vebe time suggests a stiffer mix with lower workability.
Certified MTP offers all the vibration testing equipment you need to carry out the Vebe test to determine the workability and consistency of your fresh concrete.
What is the relationship between concrete workability and consistency in concrete?
Let’s clarify the importance of concrete workability and its connection to consistency.
Achieving a proper mix is crucial to ensure the desired consistency and workability. Workability is a measure of how easily you can mix, place, and compact concrete. Concrete with good workability is easy to handle, spread, and finish, making it suitable for various construction applications.
Consistency describes the fluidity or stiffness of the concrete. It describes the state or texture of the concrete, whether it is fluid or stiff.
Consistency includes the entire range and degree of concrete fluidity/ wetness, from the driest to the wettest possible mixtures. When a concrete mix exhibits continuous deformation without rupture, it has plastic consistency. A plastic mixture possesses cohesion and will not crumble.
Thus, consistency and the workability of concrete are closely related; a concrete mix with the desired consistency will generally result in good workability. Get consistency wrong, and you have an unworkable material, essentially useless for many construction purposes.
Is there a difference between workability and consistency in concrete?
Concrete workability and consistency are interrelated but distinct properties.
Workability is a broader property that describes how easy to use concrete is, while consistency describes the texture of the concrete (whether it is fluid or stiff). So consistency is a more specific aspect of workability.
What is the Relevant IS code for consistency test on concrete?
The most popular test method for the consistency of concrete is the Slump method, which is described in the IS: 1199.
The procedures of the Slump test are also outlined in ASTM C143 in the United States and EN 12350-2 in Europe.
Apparatus for measuring consistency of concrete
The specific equipment you need to measure the consistency of concrete depends on the test method. Using a bagged concrete mix is convenient and cost-effective for small home projects, as it simplifies the process and reduces waste.
Apparatus needed for Slump test
To measure the consistency of concrete using the Slump test, you’ll need the following equipment:
- Slump cone: It’s a frustum of a cone, which you’ll use to make the concrete cone.
- Non-porous base plate: You’ll make the concrete cone and do the test on the base plate.
- Slump cone filling funnel: To help you place the concrete into the slump cone with minimal spillage.
- Sample scoop: To scoop concrete into the slump cone.
- Tamping rod: To tamp the concrete in the slump cone to ensure uniform compaction and reduce voids that may affect the accuracy of the result.
- Trowel: To make the concrete in the slump cone level with the top of the cone.
- Steel rod: To gauge the vertical displacement of the concrete cone after it slumps.
- Measuring tape: To measure the exact slump of the concrete cone.
- Scrub brush: To clean concrete spills on the base plate (around the concrete cone).
Apparatus needed for flow table test
To measure the consistency of concrete using a flow table test, you’ll need the following equipment:
- Flow table. Where you put the mold and make the concrete cone
- Flow mold. A frustum of a cone for making the concrete mold to test its flow.
- Hand scoop. To fill the mold.
- Tamping rod. To tamp the concrete in the mold.
- Steel straight edge. To strike off excess concrete from the top of the mold.
- Percent flow caliper. To measure the spread of the concrete.
Apparatus needed for Vebe test
To measure the workability and consistency of concrete using the Vebe test, you need the following apparatus.
- Vebe consistometer. It consists of a vibrating table, a clear plastic disc, and a conical frustum placed in a larger hollow cylinder. The apparatus is for creating the concrete cone and vibrating it until it flattens.
- Tamping rod. To tamp the concrete to ensure uniform compaction.
- Stopwatch. To measure how long the concrete will take to flatten and touch all parts of the transparent disc.
- Scoop. To scoop concrete into the mold to create the concrete cone.
- Trowel. To strike off excess concrete from the cone’s top.
Procedure for testing the consistency of concrete
The procedure for testing the consistency of concrete also depends on the test method you use. Proper mixing techniques are crucial to ensure the consistency of mixed concrete, which is essential for obtaining accurate test results.
Procedures for testing the consistency of concrete using the Slump test
The procedures for measuring the consistency of concrete using the popular Slump test are as follows:
- Place the slump cone on the flat base plate.
- Open the bag of concrete and prepare the mix. Fill one-third of the slump cone with the prepared concrete mix and tamp 25 times with the rod.
- Fill another one-third of the cone and tamp 25 times. Fill the last one-third of the cone and tamp 25 times.
- Remove excess concrete from the top of the cone, using a trowel to ensure the concrete is leveled with the cone’s top.
- Carefully lift the cone off the concrete. The concrete will slump (subside) when the cone comes off.
- Place the cone upside down next to the concrete, then place a rod across the top of the cone so it overhangs the concrete.
- Measure the slump by checking the vertical distance between the rod and the top of the slumped concrete. The slump is measured to the nearest 5mm.
Related Blogs
A Complete Guide to Slump Test Concrete: Methods, Tips & Significance
Using Slump Cones in Concrete Testing: Mastering Workability
